Showing posts with label Brand Personality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Brand Personality. Show all posts

Saturday, May 3, 2008

The Summer Collection...


The recent spate of rebranding initiatives clearly indicates the state of mind of a lot of managements in the country. Brand is high on priority but low on understanding. However there is some interesting work some not so great.
On the whole, here is what I felt of the 3 that I have noticed.
Shoppers is a pretty neat job of making the retailer future ready. The new logo has all the understated class and cosmopolitan feel of the brand while keeping it very accessible. The line- Start Something New – really is awful. Not only is it copied, it is so passé that it undoes some of the ground covered by the logo.
As Luke Sullivan says in Hey Whipple Squeeze This- If you don’t have a ‘just do it’, just don’t!
Godrej, I feel has gone a few decades back and somewhere the confused identity is leaping out. The new logo looks terribly inspired by Google and that is certainly a little too much for Godrej to replicate. However, it is pretty clear that Interbrand has not developed a strong sense of what Godrej has meant over the decades to Indians and left a lot of money on the table in terms of leveraging the equity of the group. The treatment of the new logo is terribly out of character with the group’s overall enduring, dignified and classy appeal.
I feel strongly about Ceat though. I feel it has shot itself in the foot by taking the rhino out. Metaphors like these are hard to come by. A gattu (Asian Paints), a Maharaja etc. have been few and far between and one wonders what kind of managements are not gotten by a great idea when they see one. In an earlier post I had written about the power of a Branding Idea.
To me Ceat getting rid of the rhino is a form of hara-kiri as other than that logo I can’t think of anything distinctive the company had going for itself for a while. The new logo is another one of those idealess logos where reams of longwinded explanation will be provided about every color, every nuance and every brushstroke that has gone into that logo but ask the consumer to interpret it and not even 1% of that will be played back.

What's in a Name!


The amount of agonizing I usually see over naming issues in companies makes me wonder if it is all worth it. Just to qualify, I have nothing against a truckload of creativity in naming a company ( a la innocent, Apple etc.) but when I see massive amount of management time being spent on commoditized businesses running under absolutely bland family names I wonder What’s really in a name?
Recently came across a client dilemma. An industrial business (B2B) has been operating under a certain name (a generic English word) across a few geographies. Now it wants to enter a new geography where some other business with the same name has already been in existence. The question is whether to go ahead with the same name and spend our money and imagination to establish our version of the same name more distinctively than the other or to choose a new, distinctive one. One would want to analyze the situation from various angles like the existing equity in their name, any regulatory hurdles etc. and not to mention some possible superstitions of the management.
However the question on my mind remains if we are grappling with the real stuff or just the cosmetics? And is it worth the time and money being spent on such exercises?
(Incidentally just came across a blog dedicated to the issue of naming - Namewire is an interesting blog which covers this topic from various perspectives and provides a lot of material to mull over).
In Indian we have had a remarkable marketing story unfolding over the last decade or so in the form of what is known today as Vodaphone. It has gone from starting out as Max-Touch to being Orange and then till a few months ago Hutch. Every time it has managed to transition to a new name absolutely effortlessly keeping the same core values and brand personality intact. Although it may sound a little too premature, there are two Reliances operating and carving out fairly distinct personalities for themselves. On the flip side there are the expensive but superficial rebranding/revamping exercises a la Shoppers Stop, Ceat, Berger, Godrej etc. that we have witnessed in recent times.
The point I am making here is that very few clients seem to be engaging with the real issue of brand personality which is where the brand gets built or destroyed and not in naming/visual identity. Only when a senior management is in touch with its organizational personality it can cause uniqueness to happen in the market and name in may opinion plays an insignificant role in it. Sadly, in my opinion very few pass that test and end up looking for answers in the wrong places like visual identity (a highly overrated domain in my opinion , but will leave that one for another day).
I have been a part of an absolutely brilliant naming exercise for a not-for-profit called Janaagraha where we identified what the movement needs to stand for and the name consciously evoked a certain proposition and personality of Gandhi.
On the other hand, my own firm which is called Centre of Gravity (not yet a brand by any stretch of imagination) has been a total positive coincidence. What is our firm today was started by a colleague who was into climbing/adventure sports and the name Centre of Gravity sounded apt for that. Due to a host of serendipities the team ended up doing brand strategy work for a few clients and eventually decided to focus on pure Organization Brands and when we looked at the name it sounded perfectly apt and incredibly creative since our work is primarily about helping organizations define the core of their being their identity i.e. their Centre of Gravity.
So, while we agonize over naming our rose- the starting point would be to get in touch with its smell…

Friday, July 20, 2007

Being the Brand!


Can a corporation/a brand, in these complex and dynamic times with short managerial tenures realistically aim for long range strategic planning and 5-10 year objectives with roadmaps? Can they hope to get some where that is clearly articulated way down into the future or do they have to decide and be in that space from day one? Are great brand built as a result of getting somewhere or being someone?


I am deeply sceptical of long-term planning lead approaches...do we even know what course our life will take 3 months down the line (provided we are playing a dynamic game)....


The only approach for corporations would be to discover and articulate 'a way of being' for themselves that inspires them to be at their best. Lets look at a few illustrations of the way of being- Apple is being creative all the time across all its functions- whether it is designing a pc or launching a new product like ipod or conceptualizing its retail experience, TATA is about being responsible, Reliance is about being wealthcreating... the more consistently a corporation is being itself across all its activities (and communication is just the front end) the greater its chance of achieving true uniqueness...so now the question arises how does a brand discover its way of being! Can you look at the most powerful, iconic brands and distinguish a consistent way of being?


Watch out for more on this as this space unfolds...

Monday, May 21, 2007

The Modern Indian Holy Trinity




Looking at Aamir, Rehman and Sachin, I have always wondered about the striking parallels between them. The post 90s generation has been lucky to have these three absolutely world-class performers setting new standards in each of the three uniting passions of this nation.


All of them have somewhere reinforced our faith in our abilities to take on the best in the world in our respctive fields. Their single minded, almost obsessive devotion to their respective crafts, the extremely private existence beyond their profession, and an unbelievable refusal to succumb to any of the power/celebrity temptations of their success is something which has natural resonance with most of us.
Isn't it interesting how even physically these three guys are remarkably similar with their short height, curly locks and baby faces? Wonder if there is a common archetype at the heart of it all!


When a nation is on an economic upswing, its ascendancy is also felt across other fields like cuture, sports and entertainment.


Today, the Indian soft power has something more to offer beyond yoga, henna and tandoori chicken as Rehman breaks all language barriers to take Indian music to different parts of the world. Sachin's fearless strokeplay provided the confidence in our players to take on the likes of Australia and Pakistan and our cricket witnessed its gloden-est period ever with the likes of Dravid, Ganguly, Laxman and Kumble forming the kernel of a fairly successful outfit. Aamir demonstrated that being a super-star and being an outstanding actor were not mutually exclusive (fans of Shahrukh and Amitabh may disagree, but my strong views on their acting skills will be the subject of another blog).


While Rehman and Sachin have managed to have stable marriages, Aamir's divorce after nearly a decade of marriage continues to be looked at as one sour note in an otherwise clean celebrity life, by quite a few of his fans.


These three guys emerged towards the late 80s early 90s and have consistently provided us all with one sublime performance after another. From the looks of it, while Rehman and Aamir continue to reinvent themselves, Sachin is still searching for some direction for the next phase of his career. It will be of interest to see if these guys reinvent themselves in a manner that is befitting their stature. If i were to risk some crystal gazing, I see an opportunity for Rehman to outdo a certain Reshammiya to emerge as the first truly global rock star out of India; Sachin clearly has role models in Gavaskar and Vijay Amritraj to build a great career beyond playing cricket and Aamir most certainly is a director to look forward to.


Hopefully, there is still lots more magic left with these maestros for a few more decades of pure joy.